Let’s be honest: there’s a persistent, nagging fear in most enterprise boardrooms. Brands know they need to reach Canada’s increasingly diverse consumer base, but the fear of “getting it wrong”, of being too specific and alienating the “general” audience, is paralyzing. So, they compromise. They aim for a broad, sanitized “we see everyone” message that, ironically, ends up connecting with no one. It’s a waste of budget and a missed opportunity, because playing it safe is the quickest way to stay irrelevant.
Multicultural audiences in Canada represent enormous commercial opportunity, yet still receive a fraction of total marketing investment, according to Strategy magazine. The problem isn’t just underinvestment. It’s that much of what does get spent gets diluted into campaigns too generic to build any real cultural trust.
What the research actually shows
MAGNA and SXM Media tested three types of advertising with AAPI, Black, and Hispanic audiences: general market ads, blanket multicultural ads, and culture-specific ads. Culture-specific ads won by a clear margin, delivering an 8% increase in brand relevance over blanket multicultural ads, according to their published findings. General market ads came last on nearly every measure, including brand favourability, perceived relevance, and emotional connection.
The finding is worth sitting with. A campaign designed to reach everyone performed worse with diverse audiences than one designed specifically for them.
Why specificity builds trust
Canada’s diverse consumers are not a monolith. The values and experiences of a first-generation newcomer, an Indigenous professional, and a second-generation South Asian Canadian overlap in some areas and differ significantly in others. A single sweeping narrative flattens those distinctions. When a brand lumps distinct communities under a vague “we celebrate everyone” message, it tends to signal a lack of genuine understanding rather than genuine inclusion.
When advertising reflects a community’s culture specifically, 61% of Hispanic consumers are more likely to try the advertised brand, according to multicultural marketing research by Refuel Agency. Broad cross-cultural appeals simply don’t move the needle in the same way.
What this means for strategy
Culturally specific campaigns require a different planning process. It means identifying which communities represent real growth opportunities for a given product, then investing in co-creation with people from those communities rather than consulting them as an afterthought. It means accepting that a campaign built for one audience doesn’t need to carry the weight of speaking to all of them.
It also means shifting how success gets measured. Reach across a diffuse audience is a much weaker signal than brand affinity, trust lift, and conversion rates within the community a brand has actually engaged with depth and intention.
The brands building durable relationships with Canada’s diverse consumers aren’t trying to say everything to everyone at once. They’re choosing where to go deep, and doing that well.
Learn more about what we do and who we do it for on our services page.
Sign up for our newsletter here for more insights on marketing, advertising, communications, and how the industry intersects with inclusion.
