In today’s environment, brands exist under a constant spotlight – every message, campaign, or silence can trigger public reaction. But in the wave of online call-outs and cultural tensions, the healthiest conversations aren’t about avoiding criticism. They’re about knowing how to respond to it, learn from it, and use it to strengthen your brand’s integrity.
A brand being called out isn’t necessarily a crisis. It can be a turning point – if you know how to discern noise from nuance.
Understanding the Difference Between Noise and Nuance
Call-outs come in many forms. Some are driven by performative outrage and short headlines meant to go viral. That’s noise – indignation without depth, criticism without curiosity.
Nuance, on the other hand, invites learning. It stems from lived experience and considers a brand’s history and patterns, not just isolated moments. Nuanced feedback holds brands accountable while leaving room for growth. Brands that focus on nuance rather than reacting to noise build resilience and earn deeper trust over time.
How Brands Often Get It Wrong
When confronted with criticism, two common missteps derail brands from real accountability:
- Responding defensively. Trying to justify intent misses the point if harm has already been caused. Accountability begins when brands recognize impact, not when they defend intention.
- Responding with words alone. Brands that only respond with words with no sort of plan of action and commitment to further learning, and/or donation to harmed communities will be seen as performative. No matter how well crafted the response is, unless audiences see some sort of consequence*, then the response won’t matter as much. And this is the important part; the consequence can either be decided by the brand, or by the public. If the brand’s chosen consequence isn’t enough, then you can bet the public’s consequence will make up for it.
*Consequence does not necessarily mean punishment
Clarity, Not Comfort, Builds Connection
Many brands hold back from communicating their values out of fear – fear of alienating audiences or being “too political.” But trying to be everything to everyone only dilutes purpose. Discomfort isn’t failure; it’s a sign of clarity.
People connect with brands that stand for something real. Inclusive marketing thrives on empathy – it acknowledges difference while holding firm to integrity. The goal is not to erase all tension but to lead with context, care, and courage.
When brands step forward with clarity and accountability, they attract communities that share their values and respect their growth. Those who stay neutral risk fading into the background while others lead with purpose.
The strongest brands aren’t the ones that avoid mistakes – they’re the ones that learn aloud. By distinguishing noise from nuance, responding with both humility and action, and embracing the clarity that comes with discomfort, brands can transform call-outs into catalysts for connection and credibility.
Learn more about what we do and who we do it for on our services page.
Sign up for our newsletter here for more insights on marketing, advertising, communications, and how the industry intersects with inclusion.
